Bookhawk PressRead two chapters
Cover of The Diamond Sutra, The Reader’s Companion Edition
The Reader’s Companion Edition

The Diamond Sutra

Its paradoxes, patiently explained, chapter by chapter.

Plain words and context after every chapter.

Hardcover + ebook US$39.99 · Paperback US$21.99 · Ebook US$12.99

Get my copy · from US$12.99Give the hardcover · US$39.99

Gave up on it before? In our view, this is the most followable way back in.

Hardcover and paperback ship within 14 days · Late? Cancel for a full refund · Damaged or not as described? Refund or replacement, no return needed

Sending it as a gift? Enter their name and address at checkout and we ship it straight to them. Your receipt, and any ebook in your order, come to you. Printed books usually arrive about 3 weeks after you order in the US, about 4 weeks in Canada. How gifting works

The hardcover includes the ebook; with the paperback, add it for US$4.00. Start reading while your book is printed and shipped.

Why this edition

  • Every paradox explained, patiently

    “Not merely a physical body,” Subhuti says. After each chapter the companion explains patiently: context, the chapter in plain words (our paraphrase), key terms with pronunciation and Sanskrit or Chinese, connections, reflection prompts.

  • Know what to watch for before you read

    Before Chapter III you’re told to watch for a list that keeps coming back: “an entity, a being, a living being, or a personality.” A short orientation before each chapter says who is speaking, what it takes up and what to watch for.

  • Thirty days, one idea, or straight through

    Read a little each day with the thirty-day reading plan, follow one idea through the book with the themes index, or read straight through. How to Use This Companion sets out each path, so you always know where to pick up.

  • Know what you’re holding before page one

    A printed copy of its Chinese text dated 868 is the oldest dated printed book known. The introduction tells why that matters, how the sutra is recited today, and how Gemmell translated it with help from monks in central China.

  • Gemmell’s notes, and whose voice each one is

    His notes stay as footnotes, quoting Müller, Beal, Eitel and a Chinese commentary. The companion tells you whose voice each carries; the glossary turns “enlightened disciple” and “the Law” into bodhisattva and dharma, with pronunciation.

  • People, places, a timeline, further reading

    People and places explains the names you meet in the text and notes. The timeline puts the sutra’s long history in order, and further reading shows you where to go when you finish.

Get my copy · from US$12.99

The words alone, or the words with a guide

A plain copyThis edition
“Not merely a physical body,” and you’re left to guess why.The companion explains the paradox patiently, then gives the chapter again in plain words.
“The Law” means the teaching here, objects of thought there. No warning.Key terms flag it: in Chapter IV “Law” means objects of thought, with the Sanskrit dharma.
Footnotes quoting Eitel and Beal, with no clue whose views are dated.The companion names each note’s voice and says calmly where scholars now see it differently.
Subhuti bares a shoulder and kneels, and the gesture goes unexplained.Context explains these as the traditional forms of respect before a teacher.
No idea where to begin, or how fast to go.An introduction for today’s reader, a thirty-day plan and a themes index.

Get my copy · from US$12.99

The Diamond Sutra is short enough to read in about an hour, and it can leave a first-time reader lost within minutes. It keeps returning to one paradox: what is called X is not X, and so it is called X. William Gemmell’s stately 1912 English adds a second puzzle, with “the Law” for the Buddha’s teaching and “enlightened disciple” for a bodhisattva. This edition walks you through both, chapter by chapter. It’s the most followable way into the sutra we know.

It opens on an ordinary morning. In the grove of Jeta, outside Shravasti, the Buddha begs for his meal, eats, puts away his bowl, washes his feet and sits down. Then Subhuti rises, bares his right shoulder, kneels and asks how a disciple should keep the mind steady. What follows is, by tradition, the Buddha’s answer: giving that leans on nothing, a teaching like a raft left on the far shore, a Buddha not seen through his body. “Every form or quality of phenomena is transient and illusive,” Gemmell’s Buddha says.

Here Gemmell’s wording is kept as his, with his notes. Before each chapter, a short orientation tells you what to watch for. After it, the companion gives context, the chapter again in plain words (our paraphrase, clearly marked), key terms with pronunciation, and questions to reflect on. A glossary, a thirty-day reading plan and an introduction to the sutra’s living tradition complete the way in. No knowledge of Buddhism needed.

What’s inside

  • The Diamond Sutra in William Gemmell’s 1912 translation from the Chinese, every chapter, with his dedication, preface, introduction and notes
  • Before each chapter, a short orientation: who is speaking, what the chapter takes up, and what to watch for
  • After each chapter, its companion: context, the chapter in plain words (our own paraphrase, clearly marked), key terms with pronunciation, connections to other chapters, and questions to reflect on
  • An introduction for today’s reader on the sutra, its place in Buddhism, and Gemmell and his translation, with How to Use This Companion
  • A thirty-day reading plan and a themes index, for reading a little each day or following one idea through the book
  • A glossary with pronunciation, people and places, a timeline, and further reading
  • Printed for your order, shipped by tracked mail to the US or Canada

Look inside

Title page
Title page
The introduction for today’s reader
The introduction for today’s reader
How to Use This Companion
How to Use This Companion
Chapter I, with Before you read and Gemmell’s notes
Chapter I, with Before you read and Gemmell’s notes
Chapter I’s companion: context, in plain words, key terms
Chapter I’s companion: context, in plain words, key terms
The glossary, with pronunciation
The glossary, with pronunciation

People and places

  • Lord Buddha. Gemmell’s name for the Buddha, called Sakyamuni in his notes (Śākyamuni, the sage of the Śākya clan). He is the teacher who speaks this sutra and is revered by Buddhists as the one who awakened and showed the path; scholars place his life in northern India in about the fifth century BCE.
  • Subhuti. Subhūti, a disciple of the Buddha who questions him in this sutra and answers his questions in turn. By tradition he was foremost among the disciples in understanding emptiness; Gemmell’s note quotes Eitel calling him a native of Shravasti.
  • Jeta. Prince Jeta, a son of King Prasenajit of Kosala, who by tradition owned the park that became the Jeta Grove. Gemmell calls him “the heir-apparent.”
  • Sutana. Gemmell’s name for the benefactor of the Jeta Grove, who in Edkins’s note buys the garden from Prince Jeta for the Buddha; he is known in Sanskrit as Sudatta or Anāthapiṇḍada, a name meaning one who feeds the unprotected, and tradition remembers him as a wealthy householder rather than a minister. Eitel’s note 5 in Chapter I describes a different figure of a similar name: a prince in one of the Buddha’s former lives who lost his throne through his almsgiving, the story best known as that of Prince Vessantara.
  • Prasenajit. Prasenajit, king of Kosala, whose capital was Shravasti. Edkins’s note in Chapter I describes him as a friend of the Buddha’s community, as the tradition does.
  • Shravasti. Śrāvastī, capital of the kingdom of Kosala in northern India, where by tradition the Buddha spoke this sutra. It is identified with the ruins at Saheth-Maheth in present-day Uttar Pradesh, near the Rapti River, not on the Ganges as Gemmell’s note has it.

Choose your format

Every format includes the whole companion: the introduction, an orientation and companion notes for every chapter, the glossary, the who’s who and the themes.

Format
Ship to

Prices in US dollars. Printed books ship for a flat rate to the US or Canada, shown at checkout before you pay. Ebooks have no shipping charge. US sales tax, if any, is shown before you pay. Internationally fulfilled orders may be subject to customs duties or other import charges.

With tracked shipping, printed books usually arrive about 3 weeks after you order in the US and about 4 weeks in Canada.

Our promise

  • Order today and your hardcover or paperback ships within 14 days, or your ebook is emailed within 5 days. Your confirmation email gives the exact date.
  • Running late? We email you before that date, and you can keep waiting or cancel for a full refund.
  • Arrives damaged or misprinted, or not as this page describes? Email us a photo up to 30 days after delivery for a full refund or a replacement. No need to send it back.
  • Secure checkout by Stripe. Your card details go to Stripe, never to us. Your statement will show BOOKHAWK PRESS.

Shipping · Refunds

See how it works: two chapters from the book

Every chapter opens with a short Before you read and ends with its companion. Here are Chapter I, the morning the sutra begins, and Chapter V, one of its shortest and most quoted, as the book prints them, with Gemmell’s notes; open the companion under each to see what comes after.

Chapter I

Thus have I heard1 concerning our Lord Buddha:—

Continue reading

Upon a memorable occasion, the Lord Buddha2 sojourned in the kingdom of Shravasti,3 lodging in the grove of Jeta,4 a park within the imperial domain, which Jeta, the heir-apparent, bestowed upon Sutana,5 a benevolent Minister of State, renowned for his charities and benefactions.

With the Lord Buddha, there were assembled together twelve hundred and fifty mendicant disciples,6 all of whom had attained to eminent degrees of spiritual wisdom.

As it approached the hour for the morning meal, Lord Buddha, Honoured of the Worlds,7 attired himself in a mendicant’s robe,8 and bearing an alms-bowl in his hands, walked towards the great city of Shravasti, which he entered to beg for food.9 Within the city he proceeded from door to door,10 and received such donations as the good people severally bestowed.11 Concluding this religious exercise, the Lord Buddha returned to the grove of Jeta, and partook of the frugal meal12 received as alms. Thereafter he divested himself of his mendicant’s robe, laid aside the venerated alms-bowl,13 bathed his sacred feet, and accepted the honoured seat reserved for him by his disciples.

  1. It is generally supposed that the familiar introductory phrase, “Thus have I heard,” was adopted by the writers or editors of Buddhist Sutras in order that their scriptures might assume the same high degree of authority as the Brahmanas and the Mantras, “as forming the ‘S’ruti’ or sacred revelation of the followers of the Vedas.” (Compare Max Müller’s History of Sanscrit Literature and the valuable note in Beal’s Kin-Kong-King)
  2. “The term (Buddha) means ‘every intelligent being who has thrown off the bondage of sense perception and self, knows the utter unreality of all phenomena, and is ready to enter Nirvana.’”—Handbook of Chinese Buddhism. Eitel.
  3. Shravasti is variously described as the city (or kingdom) of philosophy, of good doctrine, of abundant virtue, and as the abode of immortals. It was situated on the north bank of the Ganges, about 200 miles above Benares. Much interesting information regarding the sacred city Shravasti, is fortunately preserved in the instructive records of the distinguished Chinese pilgrims, Fa-Hien and Hiuen-Tsang.
  4. “Prasenajit, the king of Shravasti, was very favourable to the Buddhist religion. It was his minister who bought the garden of Jeta from the prince of that name, and erected in it a residence for Buddha (see Julien’s Memoirs sur les Contrées Occidentales). Many of the Sutras attributed to Buddha are said to have been delivered here. Hiuen-Tsang observed the remains of the monastery formerly standing on the site of the garden of Jeta, 2 miles below the city.” — Chinese Buddhism. Edkins.
  5. “A person of extraordinary piety and goodness. One of the former Djatakas of Sakyamuni when he was a prince, and forfeited the throne by liberality in almsgiving.”—Handbook of Chinese Buddhism. Eitel.
  6. The Chinese text is ta-pi-k’u—greater disciples. Our Chinese editor of The Diamond Sutra suggests that there are different grades of discipleship. The “lesser disciples” are those who have abandoned every form of vice, and are striving after virtue. The “greater disciples” are those to whom virtue has become spontaneous, and who have ceased to strive after its attainment.
  7. A title conferred by Chinese Buddhists upon the founder of their faith, believing him to be a Teacher and Saviour whose merit is acclaimed in worlds beyond our own.
  8. Having taken vows of poverty, a robe is one of the following eight articles which Buddhist monks are permitted to possess: three garments of different descriptions, a girdle for the loins, an alms-bowl, a razor, a needle, and a water-strainer.
  9. Buddha has said, “the wise priest never asks for anything; he disdains to beg; it is a proper thing for which he carries the alms-bowl; and this is his only mode of solicitation. But when he is sick, he is permitted to ask for any medicine that he may require, without being guilty of any transgression.”—Eastern Monachism. Spence Hardy.
  10. Concerning the manner of begging an alms: “As a bee, injuring not the flower, or its colour, or its scent, flies away, taking the nectar, so let a sage go through the village.”—Questions of King Milinda. T. W. Rhys Davids.
  11. “By many of the Buddhists it is considered to be an act of great merit to make a vow never to partake of food without giving a portion to the priests.”—Eastern Monachism. Spence Hardy.
  12. “The fifth of the twelve sacred observances of the Chinese is called in Sanscrit Khaloupas’ Waddhaktinka, and is said to enjoin that the food obtained by the mendicant is to be divided into three portions: one to be given to any person whom he sees to be suffering from hunger, and a second to be carried to some quiet place in the forest, and placed upon a stone for the birds and beasts. If he does not meet with any one who is in want, he is not to eat the whole of the food that he has received, but two-thirds only. By this means his body will be lighter and more active.... He will be able readily to enter upon the practice of all good works. When any one eats too greedily… nothing is more harmful to the development of reason.” (Quotation from Remusat’s Relation des Royaumes Buddhiques, in Spence Hardy’s Eastern Monachism.)
  13. “The alms-bowl which Sakyamuni used is considered a sacred relic, and to be used by each of the hundred Buddhas of the present kalpa. It was first preserved in Vais’ali, whence its emigrations began to Gandhara, to Persia, to China, to Ceylon, to Madhyades’a, up into the heaven Tuchita, and down to the bottom of the ocean, where it is to await (in the palace of Sagara) the advent of Meitreya Buddha.”—Handbook of Chinese Buddhism. Eitel.
Read the companion to Chapter I

Context The sutra opens as most Buddhist sutras do, with a witness’s formula. By tradition the voice is Ānanda’s, reciting what he had heard the Buddha say. Gemmell’s note 1 gives his own era’s theory of the phrase. By tradition the Buddha spoke this sutra at Śrāvastī, capital of the kingdom of Kosala. The city stood beside the Rapti River, not on the Ganges as note 3 has it. In Gemmell’s wording Prince Jeta bestows the park on Sutana, a minister. Tradition tells it differently: the wealthy householder Sudatta, called Anāthapiṇḍika, bought the park from Jeta and gave it to the Buddha, and Kumārajīva’s Chinese names the place after both men. Monks were not to eat after midday and lived on what they were given, so the alms-round comes before anything is taught.

In plain words (our paraphrase, not the text) This is what I heard about the Buddha. Once the Buddha was staying in the kingdom of Shravasti, in the grove of Jeta. It was a park on the royal lands that Prince Jeta, heir to the throne, had given to Sutana, a minister of state known for his generosity. Twelve hundred and fifty monks were gathered with him, all of them far advanced in wisdom. When it was nearly time for the morning meal, the Buddha, Honoured of the Worlds, put on his robe, took his alms-bowl and walked to the great city of Shravasti to beg for food. He went from door to door and accepted whatever each household chose to give. When his round was done he went back to the grove and ate the simple meal he had been given. Then he took off his robe, put away his bowl, washed his feet and sat down in the seat his disciples had kept for him.

Key terms evaṃ mayā śrutam (AY-vum MUH-yah SHROO-tum), “Thus have I heard”: The witness’s formula that opens most sutras. By tradition these are Ānanda’s words as he recited the teachings after the Buddha’s passing. Note 1 gives Gemmell’s era’s theory. bhagavat (BUH-guh-vut), “Honoured of the Worlds”: A title of the Buddha, the Blessed One; Kumārajīva’s Chinese has shìzūn, World-Honored One. Gemmell’s plural “Worlds” matches his note 7, on worlds beyond our own. bhikṣu (BIK-shoo), “mendicant disciples”: Buddhist monks, who live on alms. Kumārajīva has dà bǐqiū, great monks, which note 6 explains through the Chinese editor’s grades of discipleship. pātra (PAH-truh), “alms-bowl”: The bowl a monk carries on the daily round to receive food. Gemmell’s note 8 lists it among the eight possessions allowed to monks. Śrāvastī (shrah-VUS-tee), “Shravasti”: Capital of the ancient kingdom of Kosala in northern India. By tradition the Buddha often stayed there and gave many discourses, this one among them. Jetavana (JAY-tuh-vuh-nuh), “grove of Jeta”: The park outside Śrāvastī. In Gemmell’s wording Prince Jeta bestows it on Sutana; by tradition the householder Sudatta bought it from Jeta and gave it to the Buddha.

To reflect on The sutra begins with a walk, a meal, a bowl put away and feet washed, before anyone asks a question. Why might a teaching about wisdom open this way?

Chapter V

The Lord Buddha interrogated Subhuti, saying: “What think you? Is it possible that by means of his physical body,1 the Lord Buddha may be clearly perceived?” Subhuti replied, saying: “No! Honoured of the Worlds! It is impossible that by means of his physical body, the Lord Buddha may be clearly perceived. And why? Because, what the Lord Buddha referred to as a physical body, is in reality not merely a physical body.” Thereupon the Lord Buddha addressed Subhuti, saying: “Every form or quality of phenomena is transient and illusive. When the mind realises that the phenomena of life are not real phenomena, the Lord Buddha may then be clearly perceived.”2

  1. “Primitive Buddhism distinguished a material, visible, and perishable body (Seh-Shen—lit., the Body of Form) and an immaterial, invisible, immortal body (Fah-Shen—lit., the Body of Law) as the constituents of every personality. This dichotomism, taught, as it seems by Sakyamuni himself, was ever afterwards retained as regards the nature of ordinary mortals. But in later ages, when the combined influence of Sivaism, which ascribed to Siva a threefold body (called Dharmakaya—essence, Sambhogakaya—reflex intelligence, and Nirmanakaya—practical issue of his intelligence), and that of Brahmanism with its Trimurti, gave rise to the Buddhist dogma of a Triratna (San-Pao—the precious Buddha, the precious Law, and the precious Priesthood), trichotomism was taught with regard to the nature of all Buddhas. Again they ascribed to every Buddha a triple form of existence, viewing him: (1) as having entered Nirvana; (2) as existing in reflex in the world of form; (3) as existing or having existed on earth.”—Handbook of Chinese Buddhism. Eitel.
  2. The spiritual Buddha must be realised within the mind, otherwise there can be no true perception of the Lord Buddha.—Chinese Annotation.
Read the companion to Chapter V

Context Here, for the first time, the sutra asks whether the Buddha can be known by his body. Where Gemmell writes of perceiving “the Lord Buddha,” Kumārajīva’s Chinese has rúlái, the Tathāgata. The Chinese behind Gemmell’s “physical body” speaks of the body’s marks or form; tradition ascribes thirty-two special marks to a Buddha’s body. Subhuti’s answer is the sutra’s first use of its paradox formula, that what the Buddha calls a bodily form is not a bodily form. Gemmell gives it in a gentler wording, “not merely a physical body.” The Buddha’s closing lines are among the most quoted in the sutra. Eitel’s view in note 1, which derives the teaching of the Buddha’s bodies from Hindu sources, belongs to his day. Scholars now usually trace that teaching to developments within Buddhism.

In plain words (our paraphrase, not the text) The Buddha questioned Subhuti: What do you think? Can the Buddha be clearly seen by means of his physical body? Subhuti answered: No, Honoured of the Worlds. The Buddha cannot be clearly seen by means of his physical body. Why? Because what the Buddha has called a physical body is, in truth, not merely a physical body. Then the Buddha said to Subhuti: Every form and every quality of things is passing and deceptive. When the mind understands that the appearances of life are not real appearances, then the Buddha is clearly seen. Subhuti’s reply is also read more starkly: the bodily form the Buddha speaks of is not a bodily form at all.

Key terms tathāgata (tuh-TAH-guh-tuh), “Lord Buddha”: Rúlái in Kumārajīva’s Chinese, the Thus-Come One, the Buddha’s title for himself. In this chapter Gemmell’s “the Lord Buddha” stands for it. lakṣaṇa (LUK-shuh-nuh), “form or quality of phenomena”: A mark or appearance, xiàng in the Chinese. The Buddha widens the question from the marks of his own body to every mark whatever. dharmakāya (dar-muh-KAH-yuh), “the Body of Law”: The body of Dharma, the Buddha’s true nature. Eitel, quoted in Gemmell’s note 1, calls it the Body of Law; Kumārajīva’s Chinese, and so Gemmell’s text, does not use the word.

Connections Compare Chapter IV: Giving without regard to appearances prepares for seeing the Buddha himself without regard to his bodily form. Compare Chapter III: The arbitrary concepts of self in Chapter III and the illusive forms here belong to one teaching.

Enjoyed Chapter V? Get the whole book.

That’s how every chapter in this edition works: a short orientation, the chapter itself, then its companion.

Hardcover + ebook US$39.99 · Paperback US$21.99 · Ebook US$12.99

Get my copy · from US$12.99

Not ready yet? Get two more chapters free by email

Chapter III, where the Buddha answers Subhuti and the four notions of self first appear, and Chapter VI, the teaching as a raft left behind on the far shore, each with its Before you read, Gemmell’s notes and its companion (PDF, 11 pages).

We’ll email the sample whether or not you tick the box. Sent by Bookhawk Press (Space Dog Tech LLC), 411 Walnut St, PMB 22412, Green Cove Springs, FL 32043, USA · support@bookhawkpress.com. Privacy

Questions

Is the Diamond Sutra hard going for a modern reader?
On its own it can be, and this edition is built for exactly that. Two things trip readers up: the paradoxes (what is called X is not X, and so it is called X) and Gemmell’s Edwardian English. Before each chapter, a short orientation says who is speaking, what the chapter takes up and what to watch for. After it, the companion gives context, the chapter in plain words, key terms with pronunciation and the Sanskrit or Chinese behind Gemmell’s English, connections, and questions to reflect on. The glossary turns his “enlightened disciple” into bodhisattva and his “supreme spiritual wisdom” into a Buddha’s full awakening.
Do I need to know anything about Buddhism to read it?
No. The book needs no knowledge of Buddhism to read. The introduction explains what the sutra is, its place in Buddhism, and how it is read, recited and taught in living Buddhist traditions today, and the key terms after each chapter explain words as you meet them.
What are the “In plain words” passages?
They are our own paraphrase of each chapter in today’s English, clearly marked as ours and not a translation. Each sits after its chapter, with the rest of that chapter’s companion. Gemmell’s text comes first, in his own wording, not modernized: five misprints are corrected and listed, and only quotation marks and dashes follow modern typography. So the paraphrase is a help to understanding, and the text is always there to read first.
Which translation is this, and what does the book contain?
William Gemmell’s 1912 translation from Kumārajīva’s Chinese, made with help from Buddhist monks in central China whom he thanks in his preface, and published in London in 1912. The book prints the sutra with his dedication, preface, introduction and notes (as footnotes). The wording is his, with his spellings such as “Sanscrit” and “realise” kept as the mark of the real text; only quotation marks and dashes follow modern typography, and five misprints are corrected and listed. His index and the Chinese characters of his title page are not reproduced, and page references in his notes are to the 1912 printing.
How do the thirty-day reading plan and the other reading paths work?
How to Use This Companion sets out three paths. Read straight through: the sutra itself can be read whole in about an hour. Follow the thirty-day reading plan, a little each day. Or use the themes index to follow one idea through the book.
What are the hardcover and the paperback like?
Both are 6 × 9 in on cream paper. The hardcover’s cover is printed on rigid boards with a matte finish and no dust jacket; the paperback has a matte cover. Each copy is printed for its order. Ships within 14 days. The page count is shown with the formats on this page.
How long does shipping take to the US and Canada?
Printed books ship by tracked mail and usually arrive in about 3 weeks (US) or about 4 weeks (Canada) after you order. Your order confirmation gives the date it will ship by, and we email you when it ships. We sell and ship to the US and Canada only.
How does the ebook arrive, and what can I read it on?
By email. Emailed within 5 days. You get an EPUB for Kindle (through Amazon’s Send to Kindle), Kobo, Apple Books and most reading apps, plus a PDF in the print layout.
Can I cancel, and what about refunds?
Yes: you can cancel for a full refund until your order goes to print, and if we might miss the ship-by date in your confirmation, we email you before it so you can cancel for a full refund. If a printed book arrives damaged or misprinted, or isn’t what this page describes, email a photo up to 30 days after delivery and we refund in full or send a replacement where we can, without asking for it back; the same applies if tracking shows no movement for 10 business days. Because each copy is printed for its order, undamaged books can’t be taken back. Details at bookhawkpress.com/refunds.
Who is Bookhawk Press?
An independent publisher based in the United States that sells its books direct from its own site. Questions are welcome at support@bookhawkpress.com.
What is the hardcover like?
A hardcover to keep or to give: 6 × 9 inches, 142 pages, cream paper. The cover is printed on rigid boards, matte finish, no dust jacket.

About Bookhawk Press

Bookhawk Press is an independent publisher of carefully edited books in print and ebook. We sell direct from our own site, and each copy is printed for your order and shipped straight to you. Questions before you order? Email support@bookhawkpress.com. We answer every message, usually in two business days.

See all our books

Order The Diamond Sutra